

In the fifth episode, Trembles has come back to the island as a successful oil baron. This annoys Naughty who decides that Nibbles must be punished and among the chaos of zombies and soldiers he dishes out sweet punishment to Nibbles.

As the other bears arrive and Nibbles starts catering to them, he accidentally opens the wrong cooking book, a book that when opened releases Zombears. In the fourth episode, Naughty Bear is once again not invited to something, this time to Nibbles' cooking lessons. Not standing this, Naughty bear kills all the birds and teaches the military a good lesson about privacy. Naughty investigates and realizes that the Paradise Island military are using the birds to spy on him to make sure he's not doing anything naughty. The bird seems to have a camera on its head. In the third episode, Naughty is woken up early in the morning by a weird bird at his window. Naughty kills most of Chubby's voters before killing Chubby himself. The other bears of Perfection don't seem to have a problem with that, however Naughty does. In the second episode, it's discovered that a politician by the name of Chubby promises to kill Naughty if he's elected. He plows through all of Daddle's friends whom he kills in horrible ways and ultimately, makes Daddles pay.

This sends Naughty into an infuriating rage which makes him throw the present away and grab his knife. However, the game's narrator tells Naughty that he hasn't been invited despite the fact that he's already bought a present. The game starts off with Naughty getting ready for Daddle's party. The game follows Naughty Bear on his mission to seek retribution through the relentless and systematic execution of every other bear on the Island of Perfection. When the other teddies neglect to invite Naughty Bear to the big birthday party, Naughty Bear finally loses it.
